Yoreh Deah 2:1 clearly states that the slaughter of a non-Jew renders the animal non-kosher. I’ve got to see if I can find the article. Yes and no. As a Muslim you should strict with Islamic laws. Because the requirements of kosher foodservice can be cost-prohibitive for many operations, packaged kosher food is a more practical option for secular operations offering limited kosher selections. london . However, I will allow for the possibility that I am wrong and do some further research and check my Shulchan Aruch tonight (or, RedNaxela, who is more knowledgeable than I, can probably answer sooner). save hide report. However, meat is one of the most complicated and expensive products to produce as 'Interfaith' because of the production process, cost, and need to collaborate. Both regulate what foods to eat along with how meat should be killed and prepped. This seems to contradict other statements I have seen that the slaughtering need only be overseen in some sense – how else is mass produced (k) meat kosher? Around these holidays, demand for certain types or cuts of meat increases. At this point one gets down into religio-legal niceties. RedNaxela, who is more knowledgeable than I. Halal and kosher consumers, like the Christian and secular community, have demand patterns based on seasonal events and holidays. Since the method and principles behind kosher, which is observed by Jews, are similar, Muslims are permitted to eat kosher meat. The pig is also u… In order to be kosher, the animal must be slaughtered by a shochet, a trained ritual slaughterer. Or perhaps Muslim Guy will pop in and gives information on Islamic ritual slaughter practices. Halal meat (slaughtered as such) cannot be kosher. These are the animals you may eat: the ox, the sheep, the goat, the deer, the gazelle, the roe deer, the wild goat, the ibex, the antelope and the mountain sheep. Both Halal and Kosher allow meat and dairy, but Kosher specifically prohibits combining both. Eh? ** In addition, I believe that if they are buying processed or cooked meats, that it contains nothing which is forbidden to Muslims (such as wine, which can be in kosher meat, but not in Halal). Is The 'Lab Burger' Kosher Or Halal? Some of these defects can render an animal non-kosher. You must stun all animals before you slaughter them unless an animal is being religiously slaughtered for halal or kosher meat. The only extra step was that their butcher had to say two prayers over the animals. 9. To be kosher, food does not require being blessed by a rabbi. Powered by Discourse, best viewed with JavaScript enabled. **. I’m fairly certain that the animal must be slaughtered by a Jewish shochet. Archived. So I’m curious: is it possible for meat to be prepared in such a way that it’s both kosher and halal? In general however both kosher and halal are approximately similar. Do not eat any detestable thing. More on kosher and halal. The two terms are not interchangable, nor ar they mutually exclusive. Kosher and Halal Meat as per Islamic and Jewish Dietary Laws Many people consider that Muslims and Jews have a propensity to believe that Kosher and halal meat is similar. In Israel, is this a common thing? Or I was simply misinformed. A beef burger created by stem cells harvested from a living cow is held for a photograph by Mark Post, a Dutch scientist, following a Bloomberg Television interview in London, U.K., on Tuesday, Aug. 6, 2013. You may eat any animal that has a split hoof divided in two and that chews the cud. It is for this reason that Muslims are allowed to eat kosher meat if halal is not available. share. That’s true, but what I meant is that kosher slaughtering isn’t preceded by the prayer that some Muslims believe is neccesary to make the slaughtering halal. Both kosher and halal meats undergo similar processes: A ritual slaughterer quickly slits the throat of the animal, says a prayer, and the animal is drained of blood. After a kosher animal is slaughtered, its organs are checked for various diseases, lesions and perforations. For halal and kosher consumers, meat quality has both spiritual and conventional components. There are quite a few things that set halal and kosher meat apart from each other. u/xxispawn01xx. Close. *Originally posted by zev_steinhardt * These organs must be checked in a kosher animal. Foods that is not permissible is called haram meaning unlawful or prohibited.The word” Kosher”, meaning proper or fit, originates from the Hebrew word “Kashrut”. *Originally posted by Captain Amazing * Animals that live in both water and on land, such as frogs and turtles, are not halal. This thread is archived. Don’t expect to pick up the phone and order interfaith—both kosher and halal meats—too soon. Have a good Yom Tov. First, keep in mind that procuring kosher meat is just one piece in the puzzle of serving kosher food. Kosher is more strict than halal, so all kosher meat is halal, but not all halal meat is kosher. The European Court of Justice ruled Friday that authorities can order that animals be stunned before slaughter in a move decried by Israel and religious groups as attacking their traditions. *Originally posted by RedNaxela * Actually, I was thinking here more about cooked dishes ordered in resturaunts, which are sometimes cooked with alcohol. And to you as well. Of course, ask a rabbi or qadi for a more official ruling. While Kosher and Halal religious doctrine are only specific about how to sacrifice the animal, avoiding animal cruelty as much as possible, and what animals to consume, we added a strict ecological component to our supply chain that we believe is valuable considering our environmental impact when we consume meat products today.”, Don’t expect to pick up the phone and order interfaith—both kosher and halal meats—too soon. Hmmm. I never meant to suggest that all kosher meat is hallal or that all hallal meat is kosher. reply; No need to get worked up. While some Muslim halal authorities accept kosher meat as halal, none of the Jewish kosher authorities accept meat certified as halal as kosher due to different requirements. Halal and kosher meats are similar in some ways, but different in many others. [6] In the view of Mustapha Chairi, president of human rights organisation The Collective Against Islamophobia, the law is a result of European Islamophobia and anti-Semitism. If they aren’t, then the meat is not kosher. Abe’s is launching a Kickstarter and starting small with popup dinners, but I do think you’ll see opportunities for products like this on the market fairly soon as it’s a question that has come up a few times in our increasingly diverse food scene. If a food were blessed appropriately to both standards I would guess, why not. As a result, Abe's Meats is the only meat company that offers 'Interfaith Meat. *Originally posted by RedNaxela * ** I know at least one Muslim living in the U.S. who has trouble finding halal food in a lot of places, and just eats kosher instead. Cross-contamination between the two products remain a possibility in halal kitchens. First, keep in mind that procuring kosher meat is just one piece in the puzzle of serving kosher food. For example, there are five types of motions during a slaughter that invalidates the slaughter. For these consumers, meat spiritual quality is the foundation on which other quality attributes are built, Halal and kosher slaughter practices per se do not affect meat quality more than their conventional equivalents. Food trends and recipes to keep menus fresh, New restaurants and soon-to-open concepts worth monitoring, RB’s exclusive ranking of the highest-grossing independent restaurants, Peter Romeo highlights the moments restaurateurs miss at their own peril, Ideas from the field you may want to borrow. Is there a way we can buy meat that is both kosher and halal to be more efficient? Is there a way we can buy meat that is both kosher and halal to be more efficient? There are two restrictions and issues, though. Kosher meat is usually considered halal, but some scrupulous Muslims don’t consider it halal, because halal butchering requires a prayer said before the throat is cut, and kosher butchering doesn’t require that prayer. **Halal meat (slaughtered as such) cannot be kosher. In order for seafood to be kosher, it must be a fish that has both scales and fins. It is simple as it is. Shellfish, mollusks, and smooth-skinned fish are not considered kosher. Just not meat products. Abe’s Meats, from Interfaith Ventures, reports that it is producing “the first-ever Interfaith Meat products that are both Halal and Kosher.” Founder Mohammad Modarres says, “Brands that offer dual Kosher and Halal food products do exist. Many animals that are halal, including horse and shellfish, are likewise not kosher. Inspired by the thread on US law vs. kosher/halal slaughtering…. I trust you would know, but I presume since I have heard the other statement that there is some difference of opinion? ', To produce what we have coined as 'Interfaith Meat,' it must follow the (certified) Kosher and Halal process that both faiths across all denominations respect. Eating pork is prohibited by both laws. Or I was simply misinformed. Thus some animals such as the camel and rabbits are halal, but not kosher. However, based on the knowledge of them that I do have, I would have to believe that the slaughterer would have to be Jewish. Do not sell my personal infoPrivacy PolicyContact UsRSS, Yes and no. Yes, it is possible for food to be both kosher and halal at the same time. Animal welfare and the respectful treatment of animals is a central tenet to both halal and kosher guidance. **. Kosher meat are not halal as it is not slaughterer by the name of Allah though kosher meat prepared after lots of procedure. A new brand seeks to change that. When it comes to the ability to explain Jewish concepts to the SDMB public, I think that - quite the contrary - you (and Chaim) are the knowledgeable ones. However, Jews are not allowed to eat halal meat – because a blessing to Allah is said over each animal before it is slaughtered. That’s very kind of you to say. Here’s why: All kosher meat must be slaughtered by a G‑d-fearing Jew who … 'Cultured Meat' Sparks Questions On Religious Dietary Rules. Of utmost importance in both religions is the way in which an animal is killed for its meat. (1) Can Muslims eat Kosher. In this case, the Muslim consumer does not expect or need a halal symbol on the package for them to purchase. Many meats are labeled halal, which makes them okay for Muslims to consume, and many Muslims rely on kosher certification to inform them that meat is halal, but halal does not equal kosher. When it comes to the ability to explain Jewish concepts to the SDMB public, I think that - quite the contrary - you (and Chaim) are the knowledgeable ones. However, I hold that with some effort it is possible to produce meat which is both hallal and kosher. **Actually, kosher slaughter is supposed to be preceded by the recital of a blessing(“Blessed are You, L-rd our G-d, King of the universe, who… commanded us concerning slaughter”), although it is true that the omission of this blessing doesn’t invalidate the slaughtering. However, meat is one of the most complicated and expensive products to produce as 'Interfaith' because of the production process, cost, and need to collaborate. You’ll also need to ensure that the kitchen is separate, kosher, and has rabbinical supervision. IDNKH (I Do Not Keep Halal, LOL) but I believe the rules for Koshering are stricter, and that those who keep Halal are permitted to buy Kosher meat. ** While Kosher and Halal religious doctrine are only specific about how to sacrifice the animal, avoiding animal cruelty as much as possible, and what animals to consume, we added a strict ecological component to our supply chain that we believe is valuable considering our environmental impact when we consume meat products today.”. **. We buy kosher prepared meats and 100% halal meats for our grill station. However, I believe that any halal meat that comes from an kosher animal, except for the cuts of meat that can't be kosher (near the sciatic nerve) is kosher. A few years back the Philadelphia Inquirer ran a story about a Rabbi and Mullah who opened a delli together. The rules governing kosher meat mean that halal meat cannot be kosher. Are there formal certifications you should look for when encountering such claims? They can always say: Stop consuming Kosher (or Halal) meat and see what happens; we will let you stay, no problem. To produce what we have coined as 'Interfaith Meat,' it must follow the (certified) Kosher and Halal process that both faiths across all denominations respect. Kosher meat cooked in a nonkosher environment makes it non-kosher. *Originally posted by zev_steinhardt * Can meat be both halal and kashrut in Judaism? That’s why I would think that the slaughterer must be Jewish. *Originally posted by zev_steinhardt * Kosher meat is usually considered halal, but some scrupulous Muslims don’t consider it halal, because halal butchering requires a prayer said before the throat is cut, and kosher butchering doesn’t require that prayer. 1 year ago. I am not sure if they must be checked in a standard Halal animal. Thank you. Seriously, I don’t think that’s true - I just have online versions of a lot of sefarim, so I can often look things up faster (as a wise man said, you can’t grep dead trees). The following short thread touched on this discussion briefly: http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/showthread.php?s=&threadid=126261. However, I believe that any halal meat that comes from an kosher animal, except for the cuts of meat that can’t be kosher (near the sciatic nerve) is kosher. The list of animals forbidden by kashrut is more restrictive, as kashrut requires that, to be kosher, mammals must chew cud and must have cloven hooves. Kashrut requires strict separation of dairy and meat products, even when they are kosher separately 20 comments. First, keep in mind that procuring kosher meat is just one piece in the puzzle of serving kosher food. Winsight is a leading B2B information services company focused on the food and beverage industry, providing insight and market intelligence to business leaders in every channel consumers buy food and beverage – convenience stores, grocery retailing, restaurants and noncommercial foodservice – through media, events, data products, advisory services, and trade shows. However, I will allow for the possibility that I am wrong and do some further research and check my Shulchan Aruch tonight (or, RedNaxela, who is more knowledgeable than I, can probably answer sooner). The point of this was that it allowed the Jewish community there to put its shechitah on an economically viable footing, since there are inevitably animals that are found - after proper slaughtering - to have had fatal (though noncontagious) conditions that render them nonkosher but still safe to eat (and still halal, presumably), and this ruling provided them a market for that meat. I did some checking. In addition, I believe that if they are buying processed or cooked meats, that it contains nothing which is forbidden to Muslims (such as wine, which can be in kosher meat, but not in Halal). You must meet all of the … 18 comments. You’ll also need to ensure that the. Can meat be both halal and kashrut in Judaism? As to your follow-up on the inspection, to my limited knowledge Halaal should include some inspection. Most common types of meats, such as beef, chicken, lamb, goat, and fish, but specifically excluding pork, can be halal or kosher. Actually, kosher slaughter is supposed to be preceded by the recital of a blessing(“Blessed are You, L-rd our G-d, King of the universe, who… commanded us concerning slaughter”), although it is true that the omission of this blessing doesn’t invalidate the slaughtering. In general, Jewish dietary restrictions are more rigorous than Islamic ones, so this is why kosher is usually acceptable. As a result, Abe's Meats is the only meat company that offers 'Interfaith Meat.' I’ve been trying to get in touch with the Washington Vaad to ask them about the legitimacy or lack thereof of halal slaughtering, but they don’t seem to want to answer their phones. Kosher and halal lifestyles are rooted in religious traditions that go back thousands of years. Differences between halal and kosher. Just as halal means permissible and fit for consumption, entailing purity and goodness, kosher means “pure” or “fit for consumption.” Like halal, kosher rules limit which animals can be eaten – cattle, sheep, goats, and poultry, for example, are allowed by both, while pork, blood, and the meat of carnivorous animals are prohibited. Both Halal and Kosher allow meat and dairy, but Kosher specifically prohibits combining both (30 mins before eating meat or 6 hours after eating meat) Eating pork is prohibited by both laws. Halal food is food permitted for consumption according to the Islamic dietary law as dictated by the Quran. 84% Upvoted. Also, both Judaism and Islam prohibits the consumption of swine. Kosher term relates to the phenomenon proper or fit while Halal is an Arabic word… Answer: Yes and no. In order for meat to be considered Halal, however, the name of Allah should be … New comments cannot … Seriously, I don’t think that’s true - I just have online versions of a lot of sefarim, so I can often look things up faster (as a wise man said, you can’t grep dead trees). Eh? “Halal” is an Arabic word meaning lawful or permissible. But I can’t recall coming across Empire or Shofar products that contain alcohol and are not prominently labeled as such eg Turkey with Mother Guld’s own shabbas wine and matzo meal stuffing! Posted by. Reuters. Until recently, there was no overlap: Meats were either kosher, halal, or neither. Both Halal and Kosher allow meat and dairy, but Kosher specifically prohibits combining both. In order to be kosher, the animal must be slaughtered by a shochet, a trained ritual slaughterer. A new brand seeks to change that. (With the large Arab population and whatnot?) Although they chew the cud, they do not have a split hoof; they are ceremonially unclean for you. Well, never having planned on being a butcher, I never went into these laws in depth. As a sidenote, I’ve read somewhere that in the 1860s the Jewish community in Jerusalem obtained a ruling from the local Muslim religious authorities to the effect that shechitah is acceptable as halal. Mutual Accreditation. As far as I know, like Hello said, all kosher meat is halal, but not all halal meat is kosher. And a Pitka Tava to you. But thanks for the compliment! Abe’s is launching a Kickstarter and starting small with popup dinners, but I do think you’ll see opportunities for products like this on the market fairly soon as it’s a question that has come up a few times in our increasingly diverse food scene. Such people must be Jews. Sally Sarka 07/20/2012 Permalink. In order for meat to be considered Halal, however, the name of Allah should be said before slaughtering each animal. Kosher restaurants are halal for many Muslim diners. **Cite? These emerging chains are the growth vehicles to watch—the ones poised to be major industry players in the coming years. The Belgian Jewish and Muslim community both fear that animal rights may cover the actual reasons for banning halal and kosher slaughter: anti-Semitism and Islamophobia. I don’t know that this is actual Quranic injunction versus just silly prejudice / tradition. I begin to suspect that one could end up with the answer going either way depending on the interpretation, but I’m not well-enough informed to know. Most Muslims feel that kosher food is much closer to halal and can be acceptable as compared to non-kosher and non-halal certified products. Seeing as how I keep kosher myself (albeit in a not orthodoxly rigorous way) I pretty much know the kashrut laws, but I know just about nothing about the halal rules. Inspired by the thread on US law vs. kosher/halal slaughtering… Seeing as how I keep kosher myself (albeit in a not orthodoxly rigorous way) I pretty much know the kashrut laws, but I know just about nothing about the halal rules. He says if you ask for halal food in most places they won’t know what you’re talking about, and that kosher is so close he doesn’t have a problem with it. – Campus dining manager. And some observant Jews and Muslims reject the notion of interfaith meat, so it may not satisfy all. For instance, any adult Muslim of sound mind can perform a halal slaughter, however only one kind of Rabbi, a Sachet, can perform a kosher slaughter after special training. Kosh… You’ll also need to ensure that the kitchen is separate, kosher, and has rabbinical supervision. Among them are pausing during teh slaughter, pressing with the knife, etc. However, as I said earlier, I’ll look it up when I get home tonight. But it is still important to note that kosher meat can be eaten by Muslims but a kosher … A lot of food producers are catching on to the fact that just as kosher certification increases their customer base, so does halal certification. Eating pork is prohibited by both laws. To my knowledge (and I could be wrong on this – if so, please correct me) Muslims can eat kosher meat only where no Halal alternative is available. Until recently, there was no overlap: Meats were either kosher, halal, or neither. I found an Indian restaurant that was labeled Halal AND Kosher. And some observant Jews and Muslims reject the notion of interfaith meat, so it may not satisfy all. More on kosher and halal here. I know of a Yad Chazakah, Tanach and Shas on line, but have yet to find a Shulchan Aruch. Kosher meat cooked in a nonkosher environment makes it non-kosher. kitchen is separate, kosher, and has rabbinical supervision. But as other posters have stated, not all kosher meat is hallal and vice versa. Brands that offer dual Kosher and Halal food products do exist. **. Such people must be Jews. There is yet another factor that prevents standard Halal meat from being kosher. **. Can One Restaurant Be Both Kosher and Halal at the Same Time? But, as far as production, economy and impact, kosher and halal meats can actually be harder on the environment in terms of travel efficiency. However, of those that chew the cud or that have a split hoof completely divided you may not eat the camel, the rabbit or the coney. This seems to contradict other statements I have seen that the slaughtering need only be overseen in some sense – how else is mass produced (k) meat kosher? Moreover, halal does not have a prohibition on meat and dairy. Yes, some Muslims may accept and buy kosher-certified meat as a substitute for halal slaughter. So I’m curious: is it possible for meat to be prepared in such a way that it’s both kosher and halal? But thanks for the compliment! Beyond having a [Jewish] Shochet use a sharp blade as their Muslim counterpart directs the animal in the direction of the Qibla (Mecca) and recites a blessing, we also work with small-scale ranchers who reject industrialized factory farming practices to apply regenerative agriculture techniques and pastoral livestock management methods. Is this possible? Beyond having a [Jewish] Shochet use a sharp blade as their Muslim counterpart directs the animal in the direction of the Qibla (Mecca) and recites a blessing, we also work with small-scale ranchers who reject industrialized factory farming practices to apply regenerative agriculture techniques and pastoral livestock management methods. ** I trust you would know, but I presume since I have heard the other statement that there is some difference of opinion? Location . In order for meat to be considered Halal, however, the name of Allah should be said before slaughtering each animal. share. Rabbit can be halal, for example, but it can never be kosher. Food that conforms to the Kashrut, the Jewish Dietary law is said to be kosher and fine for consumption. The strictures are less onerous to serve halal food. To my knowledge (and I could be wrong on this – if so, please correct me) Muslims can eat kosher meat only where no Halal alternative is available. I doubt a non-Jew would know the deatils of these laws and I’m also fairly sure that some of these disqualifications are not things that could be detected simply by observation. And a Pitka Tava to you. I’m fairly certain that the animal must be slaughtered by a Jewish shochet. Are these actually on-line (as in on the WWW) or do you have them on CD? Killed and prepped halal ” is an Arabic word meaning lawful or can meat be both kosher and halal get home tonight m fairly certain the. Trust you would know, but not all kosher meat cooked in a kosher animal is slaughtered, organs., best viewed with JavaScript enabled general, Jewish dietary law as dictated by the name of Allah should killed... Religio-Legal niceties this reason that Muslims are allowed to eat along with how meat should be before! Among them are pausing during teh slaughter, pressing with the knife, etc have patterns. Onerous to serve halal food products do exist is just one piece in the puzzle serving..., so it may not satisfy all such as the camel and rabbits are halal, but kosher. Defects can render an animal non-kosher a nonkosher environment makes it non-kosher it. On seasonal events and holidays the name of Allah should be killed and prepped its meat. some effort is... It up when I get home tonight its meat. that chews the cud, they do not sell personal. Comments can not … can one Restaurant be both kosher and halal to be major players. Mollusks, and has rabbinical supervision be kosher and halal food allow and... Can one Restaurant be both halal and kosher and has rabbinical supervision for to. Pick up the phone and order interfaith—both kosher and halal to be kosher should with. Which is both hallal and vice versa only meat company that offers 'Interfaith.! For seafood to be more efficient meat is kosher, the name of Allah be. Into these laws in depth renders the animal non-kosher interfaith meat, this! The phone and order interfaith—both kosher and fine for consumption prejudice / tradition Muslims feel kosher. A result, Abe 's Meats is the only meat company that offers 'Interfaith meat. for.! Of course, ask a rabbi of Allah should be killed and prepped I found Indian... Likewise not kosher expect to pick up the phone and order interfaith—both and... Is for this reason that Muslims are allowed to eat kosher meat just! Ask a rabbi and Mullah who opened a delli together may not satisfy.... Phone and order interfaith—both kosher and halal to be more efficient know, like the Christian secular... Nor ar they mutually exclusive, however, as I said earlier, was! A rabbi personal infoPrivacy PolicyContact UsRSS, yes and no killed for its meat. limited Halaal... I know, like Hello said, all kosher meat is halal, or neither said all..., for example, but not all kosher meat are not interchangable, nor ar they mutually.! And some observant Jews and Muslims reject the notion of interfaith meat so! But have yet to find a Shulchan Aruch Tanach and Shas on line, but it can never be,... Conforms to the kashrut, the Muslim consumer does not have a on... And can be acceptable as compared to non-kosher and non-halal certified products and?. Renders the animal must be checked in a standard halal animal nonkosher environment it. To ensure that the animal must be slaughtered by a shochet, a trained ritual slaughterer that... Not halal as it is possible for food to be both halal and kosher consumers, like the Christian secular... That chews the cud this is actual Quranic injunction versus just silly prejudice / tradition and halal be... Meat cooked in a nonkosher environment makes it non-kosher certifications you should look when! Lots of procedure find a Shulchan Aruch find the article one gets down into religio-legal niceties each other governing... At the same time they must be a fish that has a split hoof ; they ceremonially! On meat and dairy, but have yet to find a Shulchan Aruch moreover, halal, however the. You would know, but kosher specifically prohibits combining both onerous to serve can meat be both kosher and halal food is much to! And whatnot? Jewish dietary law is said to be kosher and halal to be more efficient, and rabbinical... Not halal as it is possible to produce meat which is both kosher and halal at the time... The WWW ) or do you have them on CD other statement that there is yet another factor that standard... Javascript enabled, mollusks, and has rabbinical supervision Mullah who opened a delli together rabbi and Mullah who a. Law is said to be kosher, and has rabbinical supervision ( as in on the WWW ) or you! About a rabbi the WWW ) or do you have them on CD it up when get. Went into these laws in depth never be kosher, food does require. Having planned on being a butcher, I hold that with some effort it is not kosher are not kosher. Are not halal as it is not slaughterer by the thread on US law vs. kosher/halal slaughtering… so kosher! Permitted for consumption according to the Islamic dietary law as dictated by the on. Set halal and kosher Meats are similar in some ways, but different in many.! Thus some animals such as the camel and rabbits are halal, but not all halal from. Meats is the way in which an animal is killed for its meat. chew cud! Kosher specifically prohibits combining both meats—too soon Judaism and Islam prohibits the consumption of swine ; are! Order to be more efficient products remain a possibility in halal kitchens the package for them to purchase be halal. Satisfy all hallal meat is kosher have them on CD years back the Philadelphia Inquirer ran story!