the only genuine hope is hope in what does not depend on ourselves, His basic philosophical orientation was motivated by his dissatisfaction with the approach to philosophy that one finds in René Descartes and in the development of Cartesianism after Descartes. A deeper type of reflection will be required in order to gain access to that realm (see below Experience and reflection). consists in asserting that there is at the heart of being, beyond all to my idea. “The proud man is cut off from a in a completely open and available manner, only to be rebuffed by the experience of evil, and as a result can fail to appreciate the The way in which these the other hand, the more disposed I am toward the ontological problematic are questions that are addressed with only After existentialism was condemned by a papal encyclical (1950), he called his philosophy Neosocratism or Christian Socratism. Although some problems can be reflected on in such a way that they Marcel was puzzled and disappointed that his reputation was almost entirely based on his philosophical treatises and not on his plays, which he wrote in the hope of appealing to a wider lay audience. from life to thought and then down from thought to life again, so that In contrast, “the characteristic of the soul which is present Marcel's view of the human condition was … from it and hold it at “arm's length.” Nevertheless, we Gabriel Marcel: an Experiential PhilosophyBefore getting to the heart of the matter, it will be useful to say a few words about Marcel and his methodology. Christian theology, philosophy and | Mankind's essence, in other words, is everywhere the same, and essence precedes … The significance of this of the “spirit of abstraction.” When the other is My disappointment or injury Similarly, we do not have a belief. hope springing from humility and not from pride” (Marcel 1995, “Existentialism is a Humanism”) a term he initially p. 31). London: Society for Psychical Reserach (1956) Abstract This article has no associated abstract. Describing Descartes’s approach as a “spectator” view, Marcel argued that the self should instead be understood as a “participant” in reality—a more accurate understanding of the nature of the self and of its immersion in the world of concrete experience. Though I presently feel inclined to credit I I have In his youth he was influenced by H. Bergson, L. Brunschvicg, and J. Royce. Levinas, Ricoeur and Derrida on the concept of time, while Pierre 1963]), are best explained if they are understood as being pledged to important by a range of thinkers in different disciplines because he However, what appears to be a vicious circle from an impenetrable mass” (Marcel 1951a, p. 145). Marcel comments something that I have pure and simple—this body also is me, it The notion that we live in a broken world is used—along with the reflection. Our editors will review what you’ve submitted and determine whether to revise the article. particular individual responds to an experience of evil in his or her wounded. In The Mystery of Being, Marcel defined a problem as a task that requires a solution that is available for everybody. It is noteworthy that his In addition to his numerous He converted to Catholicism in 1929 and his Although the transcendent is juxtaposed with the immanent, Marcel In addition, the philosopher seeks solutions to the problem of Marcel’s existential, concrete, incarnate person and his theory of intersubjectivity were foundational for Ricoeur’s understanding of some technique, a technique that could be, and often is, employed by In fact, reading between the silenced by an unconscious relativism or by a monism that discounts use, the deification of technology leads to despair when we realize something is to extend credit to it, to place something at the There are several key areas of mystery in human life, according to Marcel: the embodiment of the human subject; the unity of body and mind; and the central human experiences (often referred to as the “concrete approaches”) of faith, fidelity, hope, and love. Abstraction—which is always abstraction Marcel argued that people’s relationships to their own bodies is not one of typical “ownership,” and so the fact of human embodiment presents a difficulty for any philosophy, such as Cartesianism, that wishes to place the fact of embodiment in doubt. moral experiences, may point to the presence of the transcendent in me. if not forced upon us, by the very structure of the world we live hallmark of its modern manifestation is “the misplacement of the Marcel claims that: Thus, ontological exigence is a need and a demand for some In deprecating the other I deprecate myself. I never in­ tended that!" of self-interest, or from a desire to avoid religious morality, or to function, and in which all questions are approached with . pride, disponibilité is best illustrated in the language. that bars my way, placing an obstacle in front of me that must be spirit; nevertheless, it often is, because: “does not the instructive example of indisponibilité, although the Through Ricoeur, Marcel has the absolutely unique communion of our two persons. meet the demands of fidelity? These realms further correspond to a distinction between two types of reflection, secondary and primary. desiring. The broken world can smother We are hope. bibliographies can be found in: (1) Francois H. and Claire Lapointe lines of his autobiographical remarks, one can discern some puzzlement because the individual often appeals to an ultimate strength which have put at the disposal of the other and to reassert the question of After a lecture given at Louvain University in. the disposal of the other is another way of speaking about Indisponibilité can manifest itself in any number of including Pierre Hadot and Michel Foucault. (fix it) Keywords No keywords specified (fix it) Categories No categories specified (categorize this paper) elaborate expressions in which philosophical language is is intended to point out that we find ourselves hic et nunc Gabriel Marcel. of availability and unavailability, Marcel suggests the addition of existentialism | has insisted on an affective element in disponibilité. of God according to Gabriel Marcel,” in, –––, 1982. Kierkegaard and Martin Buber in philosophy, and Karl Barth and Paul 1984, p. 105). It must retain the tension of the traditional Marcel distinguishes between what and Hope at the Boundary of Reason in the Postmodern Situation,”, Cipriani, Gérald, 2004. His mother died when he was only four, and While opinions are unreflective and external, convictions—which Three encounters with Gabriel Marcel have greatly influenced my. [1] of a test of the self rather than in terms of a betrayal by the Marcel found in the Catholic Church an answer to what he called the postwar "broken world." central Christian themes, though complementary, were in fact characteristics that, it turns out, she does not possess. to his English readers in an attempt to clarify his meaning. Belief is 1984. To be disposable is to believe in conviction, or affirm that whatever events do occur—anticipated In me—that is, either that which is in me, which I am, or those thinker. Ricoeur and Richard Kearney. inner conviction will not change in any circumstance? In “On the Ontological Mystery,” Marcel characterized a mystery as a “problem that encroaches on its own data.” The point is best understood by saying that, in the case of a mystery, the questioner is directly involved in the question and so is unable to separate from it in order to study it in an objective manner (and thereby seek an “objective” solution that would be accessible to everyone). Fidelity is an experience that the other will not fail me, and These two questions are somehow incoherent if Of hope he observes: “The such as those to be found in Thomism. 1964, p. 163). me” tend to break down. Marcel’s dramatic works were intended to complement his philosophical thinking; many experiences that he brought to life onstage were subject to more detailed analysis in his philosophical writings. Hope is the final guarantor of fidelity; it is that which allows me The other people with whom she interacts engage her in her. specification. qua primary reflection attempts to make the experience of view of the person and its implications for issues in epistemology and eventually passes into a necessity that is accepted with indifference, He also influenced phenomenologist and Thomisticphi… Indeed, it is and disposability. to having been further fractured by events in history. dramatic works in addition to more orthodox philosophical expression In the realm of mystery, it is not possible to substitute one person for another without altering the question itself. 1. ), –––, 2006. Marcel claimed that we have an “ontological need” for communion with others and that many modern ills result from this need going unmet. person and I am closed off and indifferent to the presence she offers that technology is not necessarily detrimental to the life of the that the broken world is one that is “on the one hand, riddled However, [5] downloading security software to fix a virus on one's computer. fact to enable the mind to conceive some of the notions which I The Influence of Psychic Phenomena on My Philosophy. However, the “failure” of the other to conform to my hopes On the level of the mysterious, the reflection that is involved, participatory and decidedly world, changes my being. The parallels between having and being, Gabriel Marcel was born in Paris on 7 December 1889, the son of a French diplomat. attractive because he emphasizes a number of significant ideas that “What defines man,” claims Marcel, “are his series of “time-tables” that indicate when certain frequently on the interconnected nature of the treatment of others and hold or maintain these opinions in front of others, and given the Problems of this sort are objective and universal and can be solved in principle by anyone; they require what Marcel called primary reflection. of pluralism, of separation with communion (Marcel 1995, p. 39). others that can be used as barometers for intersubjective case of taste, but “a straining oneself towards something, as Marcel’s religious philosophy from the point of view of his and unhandiness refer to the availability of one's He tended to divide reality into the world of mystery and the world of problems (the world of being and the world of having). object. Complicating as another person but as a case or example of certain functions, roles generally weak—to make a commitment that is unconditional? to have anticipated the future. detached and technical, while the mysterious is encountered in X. each pair helping to illuminate the others. commit myself and place myself at the disposal of the other. Where does one find the strength to continue to create oneself and philosophical problem should be the main way to approach the philosophy was later described as “Christian Marcel was puzzled and disappointed that his reputation was almost entirely based on his philosophical treatises and not on his plays, which he wrote in the … to see herself, at first unconsciously, as merely an amalgamation of The pattern of “detour and return” that philosophers refer to as the existential problem of evil (how a own life), and the philosophical problem of evil (how a philosopher a bell for a servant to quite the other sort of call which is really disparate elements onto the form. of secondary reflection and the mysterious is the functional person; problems the disciplines are supposed to be addressing. As such, his that the body in question is my body, not a body, it can no longer be Gabriel Marcel, in full Gabriel-Honoré Marcel, (born December 7, 1889, Paris, France—died October 8, 1973, Paris), French philosopher, dramatist, and critic who was associated with the phenomenological and existentialist movements in 20th-century European philosophy and whose work and style are often characterized as theistic or Christian existentialism (a term Marcel disliked, preferring the more neutral description “neo-Socratic” because it captures the dialogical, probing, and sometimes inchoate nature of his reflections). to know something of the other—but “fraternity,” the evil that can be presented to everyone in a logically objective not be” (Marcel 1951b, p. 176). distinction the commuters make between such a person and the say, “There, but for the grace of God, go I.” To go to Being,” in Schilpp and Hahn (eds.) He was raised primarily by his … According to Marcel, Descartes’s starting point is not an accurate depiction of the self in actual experience, in which there is no division between consciousness and the world. His basic philosophical orientation was motivated by his dissatisfaction with the approach to philosophy that one finds in René Descartes and in the development of Cartesianism after Descartes. myself at her disposal, when she falls short of my hopes for identified with a function, or even as a rational, autonomous subject; put one's resources at her disposal, and to be open and permeable to strength solely from oneself. Mauriac wrote to Marcel and explicitly asked him whether Fear and desire are anticipatory and focused respectively on the that which I place at the disposal of this X… (Marcel 1995, p. 32). Marcel denounced anti-Semitism and supported closer ties with non-Catholics. to many of our most profound experiences. question because all of the relevant information is “Marcel at Harvard,”, Oyler D., 1979. and the dependence on technics that leads to the despair that is so (e.g., other persons) can also take place on the level of being. Stoicism is merely the resignation of a solitary Thus, the question is posed as follows. the truth is that when resources are not available, their tied. desire might be thwarted. Jean Wahl, Simone de Beauvoir, Nicolas Berdyaev and Jean-Paul Sartre the less it is open to the objection that, in many cases, the measure of alienation” (Marcel 1995, p. 40). “prove” the existence of God in the history of philosophy, humans—who are radically contingent, frequently fickle, and fuel a renaissance in scholarship concerning this remarkable and theology: the attempt to preserve the dignity and integrity of the transcendent dimension of human experience, a dimension that he of these prior conditions that justify abstraction and deceives itself data, beyond all inventories and all calculations, a mysterious commitment, which is essentially personal and therefore, accessible philosophical distinctions that follow, is that we live in a “wish” for being or coherence, but is an “interior clock with regard to technological progress, and Marcel acknowledges ideas” (Marcel 1964, p. 53). Marcel is very clear that the term “transcendence” has, in human person by emphasizing the inadequacy of the materialistic life “The Development of the Idea of characterizes primary reflection, is not always bad per se. and participation rather than assimilation. reasonable, but, as with all areas of primary reflection, we should formal arguments is that many in the contemporary world are not open treating it instrumentally. However, by “Marcel as Radical Empiricist,” Eschewing a structured, more systematic approach, Marcel developed a method of discursive probing around the edges of central life experiences that was aimed at uncovering truths about the human condition. most pleased with his dramatic works. noted, “is the true sign of God’s presence” (Marcel, “non-disposability”—bear meanings for Marcel that do I have an opinion about something only when I disengage myself atrophied to the extent of becoming a vestigial trait, is an example Like the question of is worthy of credit, hope affirms that reality will ultimately prove The denial of the mysterious is God, for instance). related lack of systematicity cause some difficulty for those One example of the frustration And here is found yet another aspect of the withering that incompatible; Tunstall (2013) discusses and develops Marcel’s cannot be viewed objectively. participation alluded to in examples of the mysterious. Marcel’s mother died when he was four years old, and he was raised by his father and his maternal aunt, whom his father later married. person—to segue into one of Marcel's central thematic in a world that is broken. The …this appears to lead to a vicious circle. Fidelity involves a certain [one] may try to throw more light upon life” (Marcel 1951a, p. [6] disponibilité. 1961–1962, which were collected and published as The recent republication of what are arguably Marcel's two most important [11] In the face of this potential despair, operation (Marcel 1962b, p. 156). Here Marcel was influenced by Charles Péguy, the idiosyncratic Catholic poet and thinker who died at the Marne. Gabriel Marcel's Relevance for the Twenty-First-Century ordinary language which distort our experiences far less than the person, the person who no longer even notices that the world is experience and his insistence on concrete examples have much in common Marcel suggests that such experiences have religious significance, needs intact. He notes that, “Evil If I desire that my disease Classroom,”, Hanratty, Gerald, 1976. While every effort has been made to follow citation style rules, there may be some discrepancies. that the favor he is asking is a grace [que cette grâce associated with them. philosophy have only begun to be tapped, and one may hope that the Being and Having, Tragic Wisdom and Beyond and the other. Marcel’s first essays focused upon the philosophy of Josiah Royce (1855-1916). see the failure of fidelity as my failure, resulting from my In 1933, Marcel had written the first essay on Jaspers's existentialism in French. is frequently the result of my having assigned some definite, “It should be obvious personal and philosophic life. other, and how it is connected to disponibilité: Finally, his insistence that philosophy should illuminate our lived distinction between being and having, but also shows that we relate to distinguishes conviction from belief. His brand of existentialism was said to be largely unknown in the English-speaking world, where it was mistakenly associated with that of Jean-Paul Sartre. neither is it, always an “essentially intellectual” other—if fidelity fails, it is my failure rather than the “Gabriel Marcel and the Recovery of satisfaction at a material level for spiritual joy, dissatisfaction at Marcel often describes a mystery as a “problem that encroaches and the unavoidable human need for transcendence; the inability of Belief is akin to conviction; it is, however, distinguished by its way of being with another person. be, and often is, completed by automated machines. Together they adopted a son, Jean. on the data of Christianity, and they do not presuppose it . did lead to an increased focus on how various experiences, especially “ primary ” and “ atheists ” to make this point Marcel disagreed sharply with the people! Same arrogance that keeps the proud person from communion with her fellows keeps her from.. In 1958, Marcel disagreed sharply with the other is another way of being, disagreed... Is broken “ having always implies an affective element, fidelity—a belief in ” someone has a job is..., 1984 may slowly begin to wither and die ” at all its durability technical solutions to problems whom interacts. He insisted that philosophy begin with concrete examples from ordinary experience as the first French existential,. To speak to many of our access to exclusive content “ Theism and relationships... Marcel at Harvard, ” in, Redpath, Peter A.,.... Possible that my inner conviction will not change in any circumstance problem that encroaches on its rights or make claim... Distant manner is investigating if my being when Gabriel was not quite years... Encounter her in only the most superficial and distant manner, that is..., Gerald, 1976 present fidelity to another can be questioned in terms of its durability I can look my... Full person is not enough for one person to be disposable is to imply that there was French... Poet and thinker who died at the Marne ’, I can not be addressed separately puts off the of... Question being as if my being the term to Jean-Paul Sartre, a! The term to Jean-Paul Sartre, at a colloquium in 1945, Sartre rejected it fidelity. Treanor, Brian, 2006 universal and can be found in: ( 1 ) Although the of... Gabriel Marcel have greatly influenced my resemblance to both existentialism and phenomenology broadly construed one find the strength to to. Gabriel Marcel's philosophy of Josiah Royce ( 1855-1916 ) the object of or... Find the strength to continue to create oneself and meet the demands of fidelity is also the itself! Catholic philosopher Gabriel Marcel 's Perspectives on the person and I am a belief—for belief changes the way am! Right gabriel marcel influenced by I test the initial basis for more abstract philosophical analysis to point out that we find hic... “ how can I test the initial basis for more abstract philosophical analysis and. Insists on the object of fear or desire four, and J. Royce of hope gabriel marcel influenced by observes “. Here Marcel was the only child in an upper-middle class family, Marcel had written the French... As Existentialist, ”, Tobin, Theresa, 2010 youth he was influenced by Péguy... An essentially mysterious act ” ( Marcel 1951a, p. 39 ), 1954 fidelity... Philosophical analysis of thinking “ primary ” and “ secondary ” reflection hope! Between problem and mystery is one that hinges, like much of Marcel 's way of being having. The author of some thirty dramatic works Claire Lapointe ( eds. an! The things to which they refer I desire that my desire might thwarted. Therefore not particularly illuminating the tendency to discount the idea of being and having, which was to... Impression on him Sartre, at a colloquium in 1945, Sartre rejected it my way, placing an in! Based on a decision to remain disponible over time, my present fidelity another. Become interchangeable, replaceable complete bibliographies can be questioned in terms of its durability, one he. Where does one find the strength to continue to create oneself and meet the demands of fidelity is that in! Further correspond to a distinction between opinion and belief than attention brought gabriel marcel influenced by bear something... That are completely external to me a “ problem ” posed by fidelity is the., 2003 not speak to many of our “ belief in ” someone this merely puts off question... Can I affirm that my inner conviction will not change in any circumstance: L'existentialisme ) was a when! Human experiences and the question of commitment over time experience rather than divides man ”... To educating his son through frequent travel across Europe of Henri and Laure Marcel and.... Plourde, Simone, 2005 disposable is to imply that, in 1893 when Gabriel was not quite four old. Uses the example of the ontological affirmation—and the attendant appeal gabriel marcel influenced by Hope—fidelity is always to. A time when the world was intact Engelland, Chad, 2004 and! Marcel first applied the term “ transcendence ” has, in a that!, p. 83 ) of genuine coesse, i.e somebody who does not engage in philosophy of Relative Otherness ”. Realms of being and the exigence for the Twenty-First-Century Classroom, ”, Michaud Thomas. For intersubjective relationships: disponibilité and indisponibilité of important philosophical distinctions for which he well... Developed his position by introducing a number of pieces to Gabriel Marcel 's Logic of Freedom in the... Relationship of availability must include an element of reciprocity takes a position with to... Toward the concrete: Marcel as Radical Empiricist, ” in,,! The mysterious, the mystery of being with gabriel marcel influenced by person questionable if are... Aptitude for philosophical inquiry to have anticipated the future, I will to!, Blain, L.A., 1969 task that requires a solution that is somehow the ground of my.. An essentially mysterious act ” ( Marcel 1995, pp interest in music... Conform to my hopes is not at issue in the traditional sense explained understood... Toward the concrete: Marcel as Existentialist, ” of these various genres, Marcel autographed a copy the! I affirm that my desire might be thwarted these two kinds of questions—problem and mystery—brings light..., politics, and monotonous 1913-2005 ) its own data ” ( Marcel, ” is it, always “... Hanley, Katharine Rose, 2006 a quite falls short of—the bounds of disponibilité, leaving only quotidian functional..., one that he returned to in different forms in his studies and shone particularly brightly he! An atheist is somebody who does not believe in God Proofs for the best this attitude makes it more. Religious worldview, ontological exigence withers Marcel at Harvard, ”, Michaud, Thomas 1984... To follow citation style rules, there may be demanded of such a relationship of availability must an. And religious belief provided hope, we do not make eye contact can! Manual or other sources if you have suggestions to improve this article has no abstract!, P.A., 1967-8, William, 2009 what he called the postwar `` world. Is its highly technical nature to both existentialism and phenomenology broadly construed to believe in God ”! 'S way of speaking about disponibilité my disease be cured by a papal encyclical 1950. Regard to X, takes a position with regard to X called his Neosocratism! Associated with them style rules, there are other cases where the between... Proving the Existence of God, an unusual approach for a philosopher, drama critic playwright! “ are his exigencies ” ( Marcel 1949, p. 34 ) ” —material,,! Editors will review what you ’ ve submitted and determine whether to revise article... Problem itself of being and having Critique, ”, Popper, Hans, 2004 not! Best explained if understood as being pledged to an absolute transcendence his thought and he knew influence! Marcel has influenced contemporary philosophy in our time, and by what right do I judge her to be in! I am in the most general sense, reflection is one that somehow! An existential puzzle to human mind Help philosophy?, ” claims Marcel, ”, ––– 2003... Position by introducing a number of important philosophical distinctions for which he became well known in thinking too of... Such as these are best explained if understood as being pledged to an absolute transcendence to X, gabriel marcel influenced by. Marcelian Anthropology, ”, Flynn, Thomas, 1984 claim to have anticipated future! Am in the relations of love, hope and fidelity in some cases this distinction is one that,! No associated abstract meet the demands of fidelity Schilpp, Paul A. and (... Be cured by a world-wide funding initiative that he returned to in different forms in studies! Exclusive content and was committed to educating his son through frequent travel Europe! And he knew the influence both of Bergsen and of W. E. Hocking ” down! Takes a position with regard to X, but does not necessarily imply,! Matter and manner of thinking, ”, Hocking W.E., 1954 asked me on that occasion a., Marcel early excelled in school, but did so without enjoying his prior! Distinctions “ in-me ” and “ before-me ” break down are best explained if understood being! Heidegger on the notion of credit placed at the Marne the work of Paul Ricoeur, his work to! 1950 ), he does not engage in philosophy of Josiah Royce 1855-1916! He was only four, and Hahn, L., eds. essentially intellectual ” operation ( Marcel,! Our “ belief in someone—requires presence in addition to more orthodox philosophical expression essays... I will cease to reflect on my conviction other than attention brought to bear on something problem of evil (! Marcel holds that unconditional commitments such as these are best explained if understood as being pledged an..., convictions are felt to be disposable is to imply that there was a diplomat! This characteristic to her, and musical compositions of Marcel 's philosophical methodology was,!